Would you rather be in a successful band, but share creative control, or go solo and write your own songs, but shoulder full responsibilities for your image and your sound? I know this is a situation we won't face anytime in the near future, except maybe Nazir, who is arguably the best vocalist I have ever met. But just for the fun of it, and for my own analysis, let's look at a few people who have left their bands (some temporarily, others permanently) to start their own solo careers. Is it a good career move? Or is it a big commercial, musical mistake?
With that in mind, we won't look at Robbie Williams, of course, because whoever leaves Take That is making the smartest career choice of their lives.
First up, Richard Ashcroft. Richard Ashcroft was the subtlest of frontmen, as far as swaggering Britpop frontmen go. With The Verve, he brought life to their music videos with his style and general coolness, without Liam Gallagher's mouth or Jarvis Cocker's Jesus-esque impressions. Look at the video for Bittersweet Symphony, for example. In this, Richard is truly the face of the band. The rest can be the buttocks of the band for all I care, because they only appear at the end of the video.
But Richard is so fucking cool in this video.
Now look at him in his video, C'mon People.
He's still just as cool, and the song retains the hopeful nuances of the Verve message. Only thing this time, he doesn't have to share his earnings with 4 other random band members.
Next up, Brendan Benson. With The Raconteurs, Brendan Benson is shunned away from the limelight due to the indie colossus that is Jack White. People watching their videos in passing would notice more of Jack White, rather than Brendan (just a note in case you don't know; Jack White is the lead singer of The White Stripes) and assume that he is the heartbeat of the band. Fans of the band and their music, however, would know that Brendan and Jack share an almost McCartney-Lennon partnership in songwriting and production. Look at their video, Steady As She Goes and you'll see what I mean by Jack taking all the attention.
Now look when all the attention is focussed on Brendan.
Brendan can't pull off the frontman image la. Jack, of course, can, but Brendan looks like an uncle. I enjoyed the cartoons more than looking at him. Nice song, though, nevertheless.
Finally, we will look at James Dean Bradfield. He is the lead singer of Manic Street Preachers (yes people, the same band that sang If You Tolerate This, Your Children Will Be Next). He may look like the average uncle, but he is still quite a charismatic frontman of an uncle, as you will see in the video, You Stole The Sun From My Heart, by Manic Street Preachers.
Okay now look at him solo. He's a bit cooler now because he doesn't have to appear with the band, so he can plan the props and characters of his own music video. In all this though, he still rocks like he's still with the preachers. His first single, That's No Way To Tell A Lie is testament to this.
.
So bottom line, Nazir, I say go solo.